What Is A Soft 404 Error And How It Affects Your Website
A Soft 404 error occurs when a page appears to be missing or contains little-to-no useful content but returns a 200 (OK) status instead of a proper 404/410, confusing search engines and wasting crawl budget; understanding how it differs from a regular 404, how to spot it in Search Console or server logs, and how to fix it—by returning correct status codes, improving thin pages, or implementing proper redirects—can protect your rankings and improve your site’s SEO performance.
Soft 404 Error
A soft 404 error occurs when a web server returns a successful HTTP status code (typically 200 OK or a redirect) for a page that is actually missing, empty, or contains a “not found” message, causing search engines to treat it as a non-existent page despite the positive status.
How Soft 404 Errors Occur
Server misconfiguration
The server or CMS is configured to always return 200 OK (or a 3xx redirect) for missing pages instead of 404/410. Admin templates or error handlers deliver a “not found” message inside a 200 response.
CMS or template defaults
Themes, plugins, or CMS routing render an empty or generic page for unknown URLs (such as search results, tag pages, or expired posts) while keeping a 200 status.
Thin or “empty” content pages
Auto-generated pages (for example, category pages with no posts, placeholder pages, or filtered product lists) contain little or no unique content but still return 200, so crawlers treat them as low-value results rather than truly missing pages.
Soft redirects (redirects to the homepage or search)
The site redirects unknown or removed URLs to the homepage or a generic search page with a 200 status. Search engines treat these as soft 404s because the destination does not match user intent.
URL parameter proliferation and faceted navigation
Numerous parameterized URLs (sort, filter, session IDs) produce near-duplicate or empty pages that return 200, leading crawlers to flag them as soft 404s.
Blocked resources or robots rules
Critical resources blocked by robots.txt or protected by authentication can make a page appear empty to crawlers even though the server returns 200, resulting in a soft 404 signal.
Caching and CDN behavior
Stale caches or CDN edge configurations can serve an old “not found” HTML snippet with a 200 status, masking the correct HTTP response from search engines.
Proxy, load balancer, or error-page handling
Intermediate layers (such as reverse proxies and load balancers) may intercept errors and serve custom pages with 200 status codes instead of passing through the origin’s 404/410.
Incorrect canonicalization or meta directives
Pages marked canonical to other URLs or using meta robots directives that confuse crawlers can be treated as non-existent if the visible content is missing or irrelevant.
Automated content removals without proper status
When content is deleted, some workflows remove the visible content but leave the URL active and returning 200 rather than issuing a 404/410 or a redirect.
Result: Search engines treat these URLs as non-existent, waste crawl budget, and may drop or devalue the affected pages in indexing and ranking.
Soft 404s vs. Hard 404s: What's the Difference?
Soft 404s vs. Hard 404s: What's the Difference?
Definition
- Hard 404: The server returns a proper 404 (Not Found) or 410 (Gone) HTTP status for a missing resource. The page typically shows a clear “not found” message and contains minimal or no indexable content.
- Soft 404: A soft 404 error occurs when a web server returns a successful status (200 OK or a redirect) for a page that is actually missing, empty, or shows a “not found” message, making it appear valid to browsers but misleading to search engines.
Why it matters
- Crawling & Indexing: Hard 404s tell search engines to drop the URL and stop crawling; soft 404s waste crawl budget and can leave non-useful URLs indexed.
- UX & Signals: Hard 404s are explicit for users and bots; soft 404s can create a poor user experience and dilute site quality signals.
- Rankings: Soft 404s can harm overall site quality assessments; appropriate hard 404s are cleaner and help search engines focus on real content.
Typical examples
- Hard 404: /old-product-page returns 404 and shows a clear “Product not found” page.
- Soft 404: /old-product-page returns 200 with a thin template saying “Product not found” but includes navigation, headers, and a footer that make it look like a real page.
- Redirect vs 404: A proper 301/302 redirect to a relevant replacement is better than a soft 404 when a meaningful alternative exists.
How to choose the right response
- Permanently removed, no replacement: Return 410 (preferred) or 404.
- Temporarily unavailable: Return 503 with Retry-After.
- Relevant replacement exists: Use a 301 redirect to the new URL.
- Thin but legitimate page: Improve the content rather than returning 404.
How search engines treat them
- Hard 404/410: Typically removed from the index and deprioritized for crawling.
- Soft 404: May be treated as non-existent, but detection is inconsistent; they can remain indexed or consume crawl resources until fixed.
Detection clues
- Search Console: Reports labeled “Soft 404.”
- Server logs: 200 responses for URLs that should be missing.
- Manual checks: Pages saying “not found” but returning 200, or pages with almost no unique content.
Fix checklist
- Return correct status for missing pages: 404/410.
- 301-redirect removed URLs to relevant alternatives when appropriate.
- Strengthen thin pages with unique, valuable content if they should exist.
- Use server-side status codes, not JavaScript-only tricks.
Bottom line
Hard 404s are the correct, explicit way to mark gone content. Soft 404s are misleading responses that confuse search engines and waste crawl budget—fix soft 404s by returning proper status codes, redirecting to relevant content, or improving thin pages.
What Is A Soft 404 Error And How It Affects Your Website
How Soft 404 Errors Harm Your SEO and User Experience
Definition
A soft 404 occurs when a page returns a 200 OK (or another success status) while displaying a “not found” message or an empty or irrelevant page, instead of returning a proper 404 or 410. Search engines treat it as a missing page, but the server does not signal it correctly.
SEO impact
- Wasted crawl budget: Search engines spend time crawling pages that should be removed, reducing visits to important pages.
- Indexation problems: Soft 404s can remain indexed with low-quality content, diluting relevance signals and harming overall site authority.
- Ranking dilution: Indexed “ghost” pages compete with legitimate pages and can lower rankings for relevant keywords.
- Link equity loss: Links pointing to soft-404 pages do not pass full value, wasting internal and external link authority.
- Erratic search behavior: Search engines may reclassify or intermittently show soft-404 pages, causing unpredictable visibility.
User experience impact
- Confusion and frustration: Users see “not found” messages while the URL appears to work, creating distrust.
- Higher bounce rates: Visitors leave quickly when they encounter missing or irrelevant content, signaling low engagement to search engines.
- Poor navigation flow: Broken internal links or dead-end pages disrupt conversion paths and reduce leads and sales opportunities.
- Brand impact: Repeated encounters make your site feel neglected and reduce perceived credibility.
Common causes
- Templates that return a 200 status on empty search results or deleted product pages.
- Mistaken redirects that return a success code with an irrelevant landing page.
- CMS or server misconfiguration that suppresses proper 404 or 410 responses.
- Thin content pages (auto-generated or placeholder pages) presented as valid pages.
How to detect
- Google Search Console: Coverage reports flag “Soft 404” or “Submitted URL marked ‘noindex’.”
- Server logs: Inspect HTTP status codes for pages that display “not found” content but return 200.
- Site crawlers: Identify pages with thin content that return 200 but contain “not found” text.
- Manual checks: Visit suspect URLs and use browser developer tools to check response codes.
Quick fixes
- Return proper HTTP status codes: Serve 404 for removed pages or 410 if permanently gone.
- Implement 301 redirects: Redirect deleted pages to the most relevant live page when a close match exists.
- Improve thin pages: Add unique, useful content or merge low-value pages into stronger ones.
- Fix templates and CMS behavior: Ensure search, tag, and empty archive pages return correct codes or are set to noindex.
- Use canonical tags carefully: Avoid canonicalizing to irrelevant pages that mask missing content.
Prevention best practices
- Audit regularly with automated crawlers and Google Search Console.
- Configure your CMS to return correct status codes for removed or empty content.
- Create a clear redirect strategy for deleted pages, especially high-traffic or linked URLs.
- Maintain a content quality threshold: Avoid auto-generated pages without editorial value.
- Monitor user behavior (bounce rates, pages per session) to spot UX issues early.
Impact measurement
- Track indexation changes and coverage issues in Google Search Console.
- Monitor organic traffic, crawl rate, and ranking positions for affected sections.
- Watch bounce rate and conversion metrics for pages with past soft-404 issues.
Call to action
Stop wasting crawl budget and losing users. Get a technical SEO audit to find and fix soft 404s, stabilize indexation, and improve both rankings and user experience. Contact us to schedule an audit and remediation plan.
Other Glossary Items
Discover the newest insights and trends in SEO, programmatic SEO and AIO.
Stay updated with our expert-written articles.
